Throughout our daily lives, we see art everywhere we go. Whether the art we see is a sculpture or a drawing, we observe as we go on. In my opinion, art is one of the most beautiful things in life. Art gives us color and a realistic view of many things around us that we don’t really think about daily. However, do we really think about the ‘original’ of the art?
In the book, The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction, Walter Benjamin describes in depth the interpretations of the actual original piece of art compared to a replication. I believe that the original would have more value rather than a reproduction of the painting or such. Although, I do think that certain reproductions are acceptable to me. For example, for a Mona Lisa painting, nothing compares to that original painting done by Leonardo Da Vinci in 1503. And the value of that painting is so much that it is in one of the most famous museums protected by glass, this shows how valuable the original painting would be. So printing the painting of the Mona Lisa off of Google Images, does not have any value because anyone could simply print it again and again. Benjamin mentions, “the technique of reproduction detaches the reproduced object from the domain of tradition” (Benjamin, 221). In other words, when you reproduce a picture, it takes away the excitement of the tradition of the original work of art.
However, I also think that if another great and professional painter of today decides to repaint the Mona Lisa, exactly how it is from the early 1500’s, then I really do believe that it has a bigger value than a replication of an image off of Google. This is just because you get that realistic feeling that resembles the original Mona Lisa.
In class, we discussed the relation of an aura, or in my opinion, is that energetic feel when observing an ‘original’ work or form of art. However, the aura of an object and the reproduction of art do rely on each other greatly. If I seen the original painting of Van Gogh today, I would be filled with joy and amusement. However, this is because I have seen reproductions of his paintings is the only way I know who he is and how much value his paintings have on the world of then and now.
I also do think that pictures play a role into the ‘original’ form of a visual item as well. When I went to vacation to Egypt, there was nothing like seeing the pyramids and the desert right in front of you, therefore, which makes me take as many pictures as possible. But when I look back at the pictures today, I don’t get that same feeling. Again, nothing more valuable than the original, whether the original is a painting from the early 1500’s or a visual from a vacation. Art is more valuable in the original form, but to keep that original form valuable, the world would need many replications.
I agree completely with Eman about how we see art everywhere. I also think that the points made about origianl and replicas are very valid. Obviously something that is not the original isn't as valuable but with art this concept comes into play very strongly. The Mona Lisa example is perfect, no one wants a fake Mona Lisa picture off of Google because thats just a replica. The main difference in my opinion between an original piece of art work and a replica is not everyone has access to the original, but everyone can access the replica. I also agree agree with the concept that a painting that is not original, but is repainted by a present day artist would have some value. A replica of the Mona Lisa that is just off of google does no one any good, but a replica that is painted by a present day artist may in fact not be the original, but it definitely has gained some value to it due to the time and effort it took to create.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Eman’s evaluation of original work compared to a copy. I also like how she brought up the fact that an original is extremely valuable of course, they are well protected and displayed in museums or art galleries. I also like how she thought that if another artist were to try and recreate a beautiful piece of artwork that it would still be valuable and be important. I also agree with how she said that just simply printing a picture of the original from the Internet has little to no value. I think that art is something to be cherished and to be looked at and displayed. I believe that art also has value which is based on how famous the artist was who painted it and how long ago it was painted all of these play a factor in trying to come up with a value for its worth. Eman made a great connection to the reading by Benjamin when he is talking about the technique of reproduction. I agree with Benjamin also because having reproductions does take away from the original painting or artwork. There will never again be an original and it cannot be replaced copies and pictures of the original can however be replaced and duplicated many times. Also people can just simply go onto the Internet and look at the painting and do not have to go to the gallery which the original is displayed. This does take away from the original document which can devalue the original.
ReplyDeleteArt today is changing and we all know it. Somehow our grasp on art is starting slip in to what we would call value. Monetary value on art can change our conceptual view on art. I feel that we would adapt ourselves to see another meaning to art. Due to replication we start to dismiss them as unworthy or nothing compared to the original, but honestly, hoe many of us can tell the difference. Every single person isn't an art major and because of that we judge on the value. However the original would be more and more valuable, because we recognize it as the "original". Art replication have made art more convenient to the people. However did it help the people around us understand the real meaning of art?
ReplyDeleteThis sounds very similar to my blog post, and I agree with you. Art is a beautiful thing, and printing off reproductions of art makes it less valuable, but at the same time, brings more attention to the original. In class we talked about the other work of art, passing it around class, but there was no feeling to the actual painting. Although I’ve never stood in front of art as famous and important as the Mona Lisa, I could imagine the vibe I would get from it. Just knowing that millions of people around the world have heard and seen duplications of the original, but only so many people would stand in front of it. To stare into the canvas that Leonardo da Vinci actually touched would be breath taking. When you mention your trip to Egypt, it brings up a main point. People take pictures and video for memories, not because they wont get the chance to experience something again, but because it is the closest thing to actually being there, in front of something that monumental. Great blog post, and it is a very good topic to discuss outside of the classroom.
ReplyDelete